By: Sumner Patton, Senior Enterprise Account Executive at Suzy

In today’s hyper-saturated media landscape, brands obsess over what to say, how to say it, and who should say it. The creative takes center stage. But too often, we overlook a crucial piece of the performance puzzle: where that story is told.

It might seem like just another lever in the campaign planning process, but research shows that the platform in which an ad appears plays a profound role in its success. And not just because of the targeting capabilities or content formats—but because of trust.

Let’s unpack this.

A brief history: When the medium became the multiplier

Back in the heyday of TV, viewers trusted the networks—and by extension, the brands that advertised on them. Print media carried similar weight. If your brand was in TIME, The New York Times, or Vogue, it earned an automatic credibility boost.

Then digital disrupted everything. Suddenly, anyone could run an ad anywhere. And with that democratization came a flood of low-quality content, spammy ad formats, and declining consumer trust. The pendulum swung from “If it’s on this platform, it must be legit,” to “I don’t believe anything I see online.”

But over the last few years, a key insight has emerged: The channel still matters—a lot. Especially when it comes to how much consumers trust it.

Trust in platform = Trust in the message

In our work with major social platforms, one trend consistently rises to the top in the research we conduct: users trust the platform itself.

They go there to connect with real friends and family. They share updates, ask for recommendations, and engage with content from people they genuinely know—or creators they feel closely connected to. It’s not a feed of anonymous influencers or polarizing content; it’s a space for authentic, everyday conversation.

And this has real implications for advertisers.

When users trust the environment they’re in, they are more open to discovering products, engaging with brands, and—importantly—taking action. The ad itself doesn’t have to work as hard to overcome skepticism, because the platform has already done that work by creating a trusted space.

Same ad, different outcomes

Here’s an analogy to consider: Imagine you're on a trip with a close friend. Each time you head to a new destination, they can’t stop raving about their suitcase—how effortlessly it glides, how thoughtfully it’s designed, how little effort it takes to maneuver. When it’s time for you to buy a new suitcase, chances are that brand is top of mind—maybe you even start your search sooner than planned. Now picture a different scenario: You're at the mall with your family, starving and heading to grab food, when someone at a kiosk approaches you with a suitcase. They walk alongside you, pointing out its ergonomic handle, smooth wheels, and variety of colors—but you probably keep walking without giving it a second thought.

Same message. Different context. Wildly different results.

We see this play out in campaign performance data time and time again. On platforms where people feel safe, understood, and in control, the same creative tends to outperform. Not because the ad changed—but because the receptivity changed.

What the data tells us

This isn’t just a theory—it’s backed by extensive research. Here are a few insights from across the industry that reinforce the power of trust in the advertising environment:

1. Trusted platforms drive stronger brand lift.
   A study by Nielsen found that trust in a media channel significantly correlates with advertising effectiveness. In fact, channels considered more trustworthy delivered better brand recall and purchase intent. Additionally, Kantar’s Media Reactions 2023 report ranked the most trusted ad environments—and found that consumers favored platforms where advertising felt more native, relevant, and unobtrusive.
2. Contextual trust reduces friction.
   Research by Edelman in their annual Trust Barometer shows that consumers are more likely to engage with brands in environments they perceive as credible and emotionally safe. This translates directly to ad performance: Users are less defensive or resistant when ads show up in platforms they associate with friends, fun, or positivity rather than polarization or spam.
3. Trust builds influence through peer reinforcement.
   According to GlobalWebIndex (GWI), 42% of consumers say recommendations from friends and family are their most trusted source of product discovery—and private social environments (like group chats or personal stories) are increasingly where these exchanges happen. When ads or branded content appear adjacent to these trusted social interactions, it amplifies their impact and increases likelihood of action. A product shown in a friend’s story or group chat hits differently than a generic feed ad.

Strategic Implications for Brands

If you're planning media strategy for a brand or advising clients on audience engagement, here’s what I’d recommend based on what the data consistently shows:

• Don’t just optimize for reach—optimize for resonance. Choose platforms where your target audience actually enjoys spending time. Sentiment matters.
• Use research to map emotional context, not just behaviors. Knowing where someone scrolls is helpful. Knowing where they listen is even more powerful.
• Design creative for the vibe of the platform. What works on a busy, meme-heavy feed won’t work in a quieter, more personal setting. Tailor the tone, length, and format to feel native to the environment.
• Test and learn across environments. A/B testing isn’t just for copy and CTAs. Try running the same creative across multiple platforms and measure differences in lift. You’ll quickly see which environments bring your message to life—and which dilute it.

The Future Is Contextual

As marketers, we’re chasing attention, but attention is not just a byproduct of creative excellence. It’s deeply connected to the platform environment—the emotional state a user is in, the purpose they associate with the app, and how much they trust what they see there.

In a world flooded with content, trust becomes a competitive advantage. And not just for the brand—but for the platform the brand chooses to show up on.

So next time you’re crafting a campaign, ask yourself not just what you’re saying, or even who you’re saying it to—but where your message will be most welcomed.

Because sometimes, the difference between a scroll and a sale isn’t what you said. It’s where you said it.

‍